Composable Commerce vs Monolith Architecture: Which Approach Fits Your E-Commerce Strategy?

Photo of Robert Scholz

Robert Scholz

Feb 4, 2025 • 15 min read

Choosing the right architecture for your online store is a vital decision that can impact everything from your site’s performance to your ability to innovate. Traditional monolithic platforms consolidate the entire commerce experience - frontend, backend, databases - into one integrated codebase.

On the other hand, composable commerce relies on a composable architecture that uses modular, API-driven services (often called “microservices”) that you can pick and choose to build your ideal tech stack. Below, we explore these two models in detail, comparing their strengths, challenges, and the scenarios in which each one excels.

Introduction to E-Commerce Platforms

E-commerce platforms are the backbone of online businesses, enabling companies to showcase and sell their products or services to a global audience. These platforms provide the necessary infrastructure to manage everything from product listings and inventory management to payment processing and customer relationship management. With the rise of digital commerce, selecting the right e-commerce platform has become a critical decision for businesses aiming to thrive in a competitive market.

There are various types of e-commerce platforms available, each with its unique characteristics. Some platforms offer all-in-one solutions, where all components are tightly integrated, while others provide a more modular approach, allowing businesses to pick and choose the best tools for their needs. When selecting an e-commerce platform, it’s essential to consider factors such as scalability, customization options, ease of use, and the ability to integrate with other systems. By carefully evaluating these factors, businesses can choose a commerce platform that aligns with their goals and supports their growth.

Core Principles and Monolithic Architecture

Composable Commerce takes a “best-of-breed” approach, where each function—payment processing, product catalog, cart, search—exists independently. These modules communicate through APIs, allowing you to replace or upgrade them individually. This modularity emphasizes flexibility; you aren’t locked into a single vendor or a singular technology stack. If a particular microservice (like a recommendation engine) no longer meets your needs, you can swap it out for a better one without overhauling your entire platform. Composable architectures provide significant advantages for businesses seeking high customization, flexibility, and scalability, particularly for those equipped with technical resources and an innovative mindset.

In contrast, traditional monolithic platforms combine all essential components into one system. The frontend and backend are tightly coupled, often sharing the same codebase and release cycles. While this can initially simplify setup—because everything is in one place—it can limit your options for customization and, later on, make it more cumbersome to integrate new services or scale specific parts of your store independently.

Understanding Monolithic Architecture

Monolithic architecture is a traditional approach to building e-commerce platforms, where all the components, including the frontend, backend, and database, are tightly integrated into a single codebase. This approach has been widely used in the past due to its simplicity and ease of initial setup. In a monolithic platform, all functionalities are bundled together, creating an all-in-one suite that handles everything from user interface to data management.

However, monolithic architectures come with several limitations. Scalability can be a significant challenge, as increasing capacity often requires provisioning more resources for the entire system, even if only one component is under heavy load. Customization and flexibility are also limited, as changes to one part of the system can impact the entire platform. This tightly integrated nature can make it difficult to innovate or integrate new technologies without extensive rework. Despite these challenges, monolithic platforms can be suitable for smaller businesses or those with straightforward requirements, offering a comprehensive solution with minimal setup time.

Exploring Composable Commerce

Composable commerce is a modern approach to building e-commerce platforms, where the entire commerce stack is broken down into modular components. This approach enables businesses to “compose” unique customer experiences by integrating best-of-breed building blocks into their technology stack. Each function, such as payment processing, product catalog, or search, exists independently and communicates through APIs, allowing for greater flexibility and customization.

Composable commerce architecture is component-based, tech-agnostic, and cloud-native, providing businesses with the ability to scale and adapt quickly. By leveraging modular components, companies can replace or upgrade individual services without overhauling the entire system. This approach not only supports innovation but also allows businesses to tailor their e-commerce platform to meet specific needs and market demands. As a result, composable commerce offers a robust and future-proof solution for businesses looking to stay ahead in the ever-evolving digital landscape.

Customization and Innovation in Composable Commerce

One of the biggest draws of composable commerce is its near-limitless customization potential. You can opt for specialized solutions—like AI-driven search or advanced CRM systems—rather than settling for a “good enough” module within a monolithic platform. Packaged business capabilities (PBCs) are modular services that can be integrated to enhance customization and innovation. This encourages innovation because you can constantly incorporate emerging technologies without reworking the entire codebase. Teams that thrive on rapid experimentation, such as launching pilot features or testing new design concepts, generally find composable commerce liberating.

By contrast, monolithic platforms often have a predefined set of features and integrations. Customizing beyond these can require significant engineering effort, as any change may affect other parts of the system. While some monolithic solutions allow extensions or plugins, these are typically more limited, and significant innovation might be slowed by a central codebase that’s not designed to be as flexible.

Scalability

Scalability plays a pivotal role in e-commerce, especially during peak seasons like holidays or big promotional events. With composable commerce, you can scale each microservice independently. If your order processing service becomes a bottleneck, for instance, you can allocate more resources specifically to that service without affecting others like search or user profiles. This targeted scaling helps contain costs because you’re only increasing capacity where it’s truly required. A modular architecture allows for targeted scaling and efficient resource utilization, enhancing the overall performance and adaptability of your system.

In a monolithic platform, scaling typically means provisioning more resources for the entire system—even those components that aren’t under heavy load. This can result in higher hosting bills and less efficient resource usage. What’s more, if your system starts to struggle in one area (e.g., a database under stress from increased transactions), you may have to upgrade everything else as well, which is both time-consuming and potentially expensive.

Speed of Adaptation

Composable commerce is renowned for enabling rapid adaptation. Because each part of your tech stack is separate, your team can introduce new features (like an innovative checkout flow) or integrate new technologies (like voice-enabled shopping) without disrupting the rest of the store. Headless commerce solutions further enhance this flexibility by decoupling the frontend and backend, allowing for rapid adaptation and integration of new technologies. Development cycles are often shorter and more focused, allowing businesses to respond to market trends, competitor moves, and customer feedback more effectively.

Monolithic platforms, in contrast, tie multiple features and modules into one release cycle. Implementing a small change in the checkout process might require an entire system redeployment, with extensive testing to ensure that no other part of the platform breaks. This can prolong the time needed to bring new ideas to market, sometimes creating friction for companies in fast-moving industries where agility is a competitive advantage.

Cost and Maintenance

While composable commerce can demand higher initial investment—especially if you’re integrating multiple services from different vendors—it often proves cost-efficient in the long run. You pay only for the components you need, avoiding unnecessary licensing for features that don’t align with your business. Selecting the right ecommerce platform is crucial for cost efficiency, as it helps avoid unnecessary licensing fees. Additionally, if a module becomes outdated, you can replace it without completely refactoring the entire system, sidestepping large-scale legacy issues.

On the other hand, traditional monolithic platforms may require a lower entry cost, particularly if they offer a comprehensive, “ready-made” package that includes most of the features a typical online store needs. This can be appealing for smaller businesses or startups looking to launch quickly without a lengthy setup process. However, the flip side is that you may be paying for features you don’t use or find yourself locked into expensive upgrades and maintenance later as your needs evolve. Over time, legacy monolithic solutions can accumulate technical debt—outdated code and unused modules—that drive up both complexity and ongoing expenses.

Security and Reliability

Because composable commerce breaks down the platform into multiple microservices, each component can be individually monitored and patched. Headless and composable commerce enhances security by allowing individual components to be monitored and patched independently. In case of a security flaw, you can zero in on the specific service without bringing the entire system offline. That said, managing multiple vendors and ensuring consistent security protocols across all services can add complexity. It’s crucial to maintain rigorous documentation, oversight, and governance to keep the ecosystem safe.

Monolithic platforms offer a single system to protect, which can simplify security oversight to some degree—there’s typically one codebase and a single set of deployment pipelines. However, a vulnerability in one part of the monolith can compromise the entire system. Identifying and isolating threats can also be more difficult because everything resides in a single code repository or server environment.

Managing Complexity

With composable commerce, you’ll likely work with multiple service providers and vendors, each offering specialized modules—like payment gateways, analytics dashboards, or personalization engines. This approach demands skilled teams capable of API integration, DevOps, and microservice deployment strategies. The trade-off for this complexity is a flexible, robust platform that can pivot quickly as your business grows or when new technologies surface.

Conversely, monolithic platforms centralize vendors and technologies into one package, often simplifying management, documentation, and support. Traditional ecommerce platforms integrate all functionalities into a unified system, which can simplify management but limit flexibility. A single provider can handle updates, patches, and training materials. This holistic approach may be especially beneficial for small teams that lack extensive technical resources. However, the convenience often comes at the cost of reduced freedom to tailor the platform to complex or rapidly shifting needs.

Future-Proofing and Vendor Ecosystem

When selecting an e-commerce platform, it’s essential to consider future-proofing and the vendor ecosystem. Future-proofing ensures that your platform can adapt to changing market conditions, customer demands, and technological advancements. Composable commerce provides a more suitable solution for businesses aiming to stay ahead of the competition, as it allows for continuous innovation and easy integration of new technologies.

The vendor ecosystem is also crucial in a composable commerce setup. A robust ecosystem ensures that each component can communicate seamlessly with one another, even if they are built by different vendors. This interoperability is vital for maintaining a cohesive and efficient platform. By choosing a commerce platform with a strong vendor ecosystem, businesses can ensure that they have access to the best-in-class services and support, enabling them to deliver exceptional customer experiences and drive growth.

Ideal Use Cases for an Ecommerce Platform

Composable commerce typically suits larger organizations or businesses with complex requirements. If you need a high degree of personalization—say, offering different catalog views for different segments, integrating advanced AI recommendations, or rolling out separate frontends for different markets—composable commerce makes this far easier. It’s also a strong fit if you have a tech-savvy team that excels at orchestrating multiple microservices.

Monolithic platforms can be ideal for smaller companies or those prioritizing a speedy, straightforward launch. Monolithic commerce platforms, with their unified codebase and centralized database, are suitable for businesses with straightforward requirements. If your business model doesn’t demand heavy customization or advanced features, an out-of-the-box monolith can do the job well, with minimal setup time and fewer moving parts to manage. Many startups find monolithic systems sufficient—at least initially—because they want to validate the market quickly without juggling complex architectures.

Implementing Composable Commerce

Implementing composable commerce requires a strategic approach, including assessing business needs, selecting the right components, and integrating them into the technology stack. It’s essential to consider the entire system, including inventory management, payment processing, and customer relationship management, to ensure a seamless customer experience. A headless commerce platform can provide a more flexible and customizable solution, allowing businesses to choose the best-in-class services for each function.

To successfully implement composable commerce, businesses should start by identifying their specific requirements and goals. Next, they should evaluate and select modular components that align with these needs. Integration is a critical step, as it ensures that all components work together harmoniously. By focusing on the entire system and leveraging a headless commerce platform, businesses can create a tailored and scalable e-commerce solution that meets their unique demands.

In conclusion, the choice of e-commerce platform is a critical decision for businesses, and composable commerce provides a modern and flexible approach to building digital commerce experiences. By understanding monolithic architecture, exploring composable commerce, considering future-proofing and the vendor ecosystem, and implementing composable commerce, businesses can stay ahead of the competition and provide a seamless customer experience.

Where Netguru Can Help

This is where Netguru steps in. With extensive experience in headless commerce and composable ecosystems, as well as deep knowledge of monolithic solutions, we guide our clients to choose and execute the architecture that best meets their needs. Whether you’re eyeing a flexible, multi-service platform or a more self-contained monolith, we can assist you by:

  1. Thorough Needs Analysis: We evaluate your project scope, technical resources, and market objectives, then recommend the approach—composable or monolithic—that most effectively aligns with your strategy.

  2. Systems Design & Implementation: For composable commerce, we handle microservice selection, architecture design, and API integrations. For monoliths, we apply best practices to ensure seamless performance and easier future upgrades.

  3. Integration & Migration: We’ve managed migrations from legacy systems to modern architectures and can help you retain crucial data while avoiding unnecessary downtime.

  4. Continuous Development & Support: We offer ongoing consultation and support—because whether you’re composable or monolithic, e-commerce evolves. As new tools and market demands emerge, we help you adapt swiftly and painlessly.

Making Your Decision

Ultimately, deciding between composable commerce and a monolithic platform isn’t about choosing the “right” or “wrong” solution—it’s about aligning technology with your business goals, team skills, and growth expectations. Composable setups shine in high-flexibility environments where innovation, quick experimentation, and specialized functionality are paramount. Monolithic systems, on the other hand, can be simpler to launch and maintain in contexts where agility is less critical, or resources for managing multiple microservices are limited.

At Netguru, our mission is to empower you with the knowledge, strategic insight, and technical expertise required to build an online store that aligns with your vision—no matter which path you choose. If you’re ready to take the next step toward modernizing your e-commerce strategy, reach out to us. We’re here to help navigate the complexities, develop a future-proof roadmap, and ensure your e-commerce ecosystem is built to thrive in an ever-changing digital landscape.

Photo of Robert Scholz

More posts by this author

Robert Scholz

Efficient software development  Build faster, deliver more  Start now!

Read more on our Blog

Check out the knowledge base collected and distilled by experienced professionals.

We're Netguru

At Netguru we specialize in designing, building, shipping and scaling beautiful, usable products with blazing-fast efficiency.

Let's talk business